- Home
- Buy
- Sell
- ENC Cities
- Atlantic Beach Overview
- Aurora Overview
- Ayden Overview
- Beaufort Overview
- Beulaville Overview
- Burgaw Overview
- Cape Carteret Overview
- Castle Hayne Overview
- Cedar Island Overview
- Cedar Point Overview
- Chocowinity Overview
- Davis Overview
- Emerald Isle Overview
- Farmville Overview
- Grantsboro Overview
- Greenville Overview
- Hampstead Overview
- Havelock Overview
- Hobucken Overview
- Holly Ridge Overview
- Hubert Overview
- Jacksonville Overview
- Kinston Overview
- Marshallberg Overview
- Maysville Overview
- Midway Park Overview
- Morehead City Overview
- New Bern Overview
- Newport Overview
- North Topsail Beach Overview
- Oriental Overview
- Peletier Overview
- Pine Knoll Shores Overview
- Pink Hill Overview
- Pollocksville Overview
- Richlands Overview
- Rocky Point Overview
- Sneads Ferry Overview
- Stella Overview
- Surf City Overview
- Swansboro Overview
- Topsail Beach Overview
- Trenton Overview
- Wallace Overview
- Washington Overview
- Wilmington Overview
- Winterville Overview
- Vanceboro Overview
- New Communities
- Adams Landing Listings
- Anchors Bend Listings
- Arlington Place Listings
- Ashewood Listings
- Athens Acres Listings
- Autumn Hall Listings
- Ballantine Grove Listings
- Barbours Point Listings
- Batchelors Cove Listings
- Bayshore Park Listings
- Beachside Commons Listings
- Beau Coast Listings
- Beau Coast West Listings
- Belle Oaks Listings
- Belvedere Listings
- Belvedere Plantation Listings
- Blake Farm Listings
- Blue Heron Bay Listings
- Bluewater Rise Listings
- Bluffs On Broad Creek Listings
- Bogue Watch Listings
- Bradham Place Listings
- Bradley Pines Listings
- Brices Creek Harbour Listings
- Brick Chimney Landing Listings
- Bridge View Market
- Bridgewater Landing Market
- Brittany Lakes Listings
- Buccaneer Beach Listings
- Buckhorn Listings
- Butterfield Listings
- Cannonsgate Listings
- Canons Edge Listings
- Carolina Colours Listings
- Carolina Creek Listings
- Chadwick Acres Listings
- Chadwick Shores Listings
- Cherry Grove Listings
- Clarendon Park Listings
- Coastal Meadows Listings
- Cottages At Bradley Creek Listings
- Cottle Branch Listings
- Cotton Hill Listings
- Country Club Estates Listings
- Country Club Point V Listings
- Covey Commons Listings
- Creekside Listings
- Creekside At Aragona Village Listings
- Crooked Run Listings
- Crown Pointe Listings
- Dawson Ridge Listings
- Deerfield Shores Listings
- Dolphin Point Listings
- Emerald Dunes Village Listings
- Emerald Isle By The Sea Listings
- Escoba Bay Listings
- Fairfield Harbour Market
- Fawns Crossing Listings
- Garland Shores Listings
- Gate Stone Listings
- Hanover Place Listings
- Harbour Club Listings
- Harrison Cove Listings
- Harvest Meadows Market
- Harvest Ridge Listings
- Hayden Place Market
- Hellenic Shores Listings
- Henderson Bluff Listings
- Hilltop Meadow Listings
- Hickory Run At River Trace Listings
- Hogan'S Landing Listings
- Holland Farm Listings
- Holly Sands Listings
- Hurst Harbor Listings
- Inlet Cove Townhomes Listings
- Isaac Branch Listings
- Island Oaks Listings
- Jack'S Branch Townhomes Listings
- Jade Point Listings
- Kenwood Extension Listings
- King Creek At Cherry Branch Market
- Kings Grant Listings
- Kings Harbor Ii Listings
- Kingsbridge Ii Listings
- La Costa Bay Listings
- Lake Minnesott Estates Listings
- Landfall Listings
- Madeline Farm Market
- Magnolia Reserve Listings
- Majestic Oaks East Listings
- Marion Heights Listings
- Marsh Haven Landing Listings
- Marsh Landing Place Listings
- Marsh Oaks Listings
- Mimosa Bay Market
- Misty Estates Listings
- North Shore Country Club Listings
- North Topsail Shores Listings
- Oak Ridge At Grand Oaks Listings
- Ocean Forest Listings
- Old Oaks Listings
- Old Settlers Beach Listings
- Onslow Bay Market
- Orchard Creek Listings
- Oyster Landing Listings
- Parsons Mill Listings
- Patrick Farms Listings
- Peletier Shores Listings
- Pembroke Listings
- Peninsula Manor Listings
- Peyton'S Ridge Listings
- Pine Acres Listings
- Porters Neck Plantation Listings
- Porters Neck Plantation Listings
- Preservation Point Listings
- Prince George Estates Listings
- Quail Woods Village Listings
- Reedy Creek Listings
- River Bend Listings
- River Bluff Listings
- River Bluffs Listings
- Rock Point Listings
- Royal Palms Listings
- Salt Water Pearl Listings
- Salters Haven At Lea Marina Listings
- Sanctuary At Forest Sound Listings
- Saratoga Listings
- Sea Cottages Listings
- Sea Dunes Village Listings
- Seahaven Beach Listings
- Shadow Creek Estates Listings
- Shady Dunes Listings
- Shamrock Village Listings
- Showboat Cottages Listings
- Sidbury Farms Listings
- Songbird Landing Listings
- Southwest Plantation Listings
- Southwest Plantation Listings
- Springwater Reserve Listings
- Stallions Acres Listings
- Stately Pines Listings
- Stateside Market
- Stella Farms Listings
- Stewart Park Listings
- Summerhouse On Everett Bay Listings
- Sunset Reach Listings
- Surf City #1 Listings
- Sutton Acres Listings
- The Cottages At Front Street Village Listings
- The Harbour At Summerset Listings
- The Lakes At Antioch Listings
- The Mill At Heritage Farms Listings
- The Preserve At Tidewater Listings
- The Reserve At Beaumont Oaks Listings
- The Terraces Listings
- Tide Lines Listings
- Topsail Bluff Listings
- Topsail Wynds Listings
- Towne Pointe Listings
- Tracy Grove Listings
- Turkey Ridge Listings
- Twisted Oaks Listings
- Village Creek Listings
- Wanet Landing Listings
- Wantland'S Ferry @ Towne Pointe Listings
- Ward Farm Village Listings
- Wards Creek Point Listings
- Wards Point West Market
- Watercrest Landing Listings
- Waterside Listings
- Waterstone Listings
- Waverly Place Market
- West New Bern Listings
- White Oak Bluff Listings
- Whittaker Point Listings
- Williams Lumber Co Listings
- Winding Marsh Listings
- Windpointe Listings
- Windward Estate Listings
- Wood Creek Estate Listings
- Wylie Branch Listings
- Wyndwater Market
- About
- Calculator
- Market Snapshot
- Blogs
- MORE
-
- My Homes
- My Tours
- My Favorites
- My Searches
- Sign In
- Register
- Any
- $ 100,000
- $ 150,000
- $ 200,000
- $ 400,000
- $ 800,000
- Any
- $ 200,000
- $ 300,000
- $ 400,000
- $ 600,000
- $ 1,000,000
- Any
- 1
- 2
- 3
- 4
- 5
- Any
- 1
- 2
- 3
- 4
- 5
- Any
- 1
- 2
- 3
- 4
- 5
- Any
- 1
- 2
- 3
- 4
- 5
17 Properties Available In Old Settlers Beach
- Default
- Price-High To Low
- Price-Low To High
- Newest Listings
- Beds (Most)
- Baths (Most)
- Year Built (Newest)
- Square Feet (Biggest)
$1,275,000
Townhouse
1134 S Shore DR #A, Surf City, NC 28445
Oceanfront duplex with 5 bedrooms, 4 and ½ baths, rental income in 2024-2025 55-60k with Ward Realty, wind and hail 6262...
Listed by Coastal Carolina Real Estate
$330,000
Manufactured Home
7008 7th ST, Surf City, NC 28445
Location, location, location! Just two blocks from the beach in Surf City, NC, this property offers a rare opportunity t...
Listed by Intracoastal Realty Corp
$1,495,000
Single Family Home
1602 N New River DR, Surf City, NC 28445
The exceptional home at 1602 N. New River Drive, affectionately known as ''New Moon Wishes,'' has been a cherished sanct...
Listed by RE/MAX Southern Coast
$2,495
Single Family Home
6018 6th ST, Surf City, NC 28445
This is our description for the daily Summer rental site... Offering monthly through March 2025 only, We are excited to ...
Listed by Sold Buy the Sea Realty
$480,000
Manufactured Home
6025 6th ST, Surf City, NC 28445
Charming 2-bed, 2-bath canal from home offers the perfect coastal getaway. Deep water canal front with dock. Ideal for r...
Listed by Teresa Batts Real Estate, LLC
$850,000
Single Family Home
1038 1st ST, Surf City, NC 28445
Welcome to 1038 1st St, a charming canal front home located in the heart of Surf City. This beautifully designed three-...
Listed by Lewis Realty
$1,179,000
Manufactured Home
4103 4th ST, Surf City, NC 28445
Experience the pinnacle of waterfront living in this stunning home at the point of the serene 4th Street canal in Surf C...
Listed by RE/MAX Now
$899,900
Manufactured Home
9092 W 9th ST, Surf City, NC 28445
Boater's Paradise in Surf City - A Dream Waterfront Home! <br> <br>Discover this exceptional sound-front home, ideally s...
Listed by Intracoastal Realty Corp.
$720,000
Single Family Home
2005 N New River DR, Surf City, NC 28445
Charming Beach Cottage steps away from the beach access. This home has been enjoyed as a second home but would make a gr...
Listed by Blue Heron Real Estate
$2,500
Manufactured Home
3040 3rd ST, Surf City, NC 28445
Discover a fully renovated mobile home with direct water access and wonderful views of the Surf City canal. This cozy re...
Listed by Better Homes and Gardens Real Estate Treasure II
$1,275,000
Single Family Home
6122 6th Street ST, Surf City, NC 28445
The Canals of Surf City are a destination of their own, and come with great demand. This BOATER's PARADISE is perched on...
Listed by Coastal Realty Associates, LLC
$825,000
Single Family Home
1507 Easy ST, Surf City, NC 28445
This income producing home is completely upgraded and well kept, totaling 5 bedrooms and 5 bathrooms with 2 kitchens and...
Listed by Teresa Batts Real Estate, LLC
$725,000
Single Family Home
1916 N New River DR, Surf City, NC 28445
Don't Miss out on this Classic 3rd row Beach House in Surf City. Catch the views of the Ocean from the large back deck a...
Listed by Coldwell Banker Sea Coast Advantage Rlty
$725,000
Single Family Home
4053 4th ST, Surf City, NC 28445
MOTIVATED SELLER!! Welcome to 4053 4th St., a beautiful canal front home! This waterfront property offer 4 bedrooms, 3 b...
Listed by Teresa Batts Real Estate, LLC
$710,000
Single Family Home
6020 6th ST, Surf City, NC 28445
*MOTIVATED SELLER!* Explore the potential of this 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom home that has a spacious open floor plan, and a ...
Listed by Teresa Batts Real Estate, LLC
$675,000
Manufactured Home
3065 3rd ST, Surf City, NC 28445
A rare find on Surf City Island, a see-it to believe-it canal location. Beautiful, peaceful, unobstructed views of the i...
Listed by Southern Heritage Realty LLC
$299,900
Vacant Land
7026 7th ST, Surf City, NC 28445
Welcome to the epitome of coastal living! Nestled on the serene canals of Surf City, this 0.21-acre lot presents an unpa...
Listed by Nest Realty